Review of 'The Irish Inheritance' by Daisy O'Shea
Review of 'The Irish Inheritance' by Daisy O'Shea
Release date: May 18th, 2026
Publisher: Bookouture
🌻
REVIEW
The Irish Inheritance is a deeply powerful mystery novel, beautifully written. This complex story contains, as the author says in her notes, dark subject matter. It exposes the shocking cruelty and prejudice toward unwed Irish mothers and their children in the past. What went on behind closed doors (including religious ones) was awful. Child abuse is never a welcomed topic but Daisy O’Shea handles it with tender respect and direct honesty. There are some difficult scenes and retelling of incidents that would break a caring heart. It must have been hard to write those for the novel. There are numerous articles on the historical mistreatment of Irish women, especially those who got pregnant outside of marriage through romantic relationships or were victims of rape. The Catholic Church’s power over these individuals (and their outcomes) was alarming. I can see how such topics would inspire a novel. The facts aren’t pretty but it is important to know what happened by tearing down the walls of secrecy—to give these wounded and violated souls a voice. I think Daisy O’Shea has done that well through her courageous writing of such incidents.
The story is set in mythical Roone Bay, Ireland. The novel opens with the Prologue in 1950 with a sliver of Eithne’s sad story. Eithne is a twin sister of Aoife. They have different personalities. But worse, they are treated differently by their parents. Eithne, the less popular twin, is being transported from home: ‘ripped from the only place she had ever known and was frightened.’ She is sent to a ‘special school’, to her new home after an incident is discovered by what seems to be a caring teacher nun. Eithne is afraid but the thought of a place where she might find new friends and be with people who are nice and kind, gives her hope. For as we learn, she has had a very rough life. Sadly, she discovers, things are not as expected or promised.
The book is divided up into chapters with Tara, Aoife’s daughter (present), and Eithne (past)—telling the story. Tara’s mother receives a letter that she has inherited a house in Roone Bay—in the hometown of her childhood. She is hesitant to take the trip as it is a place of many unhappy memories. But with Tara’s help and strength she manages. We get to know both Tara and Aoife quite well on their journey to check out the inheritance. The stories they share reveal a lot about themselves and the culture of the past.
When Tara and Aoife see the solicitor and learn the particulars of the inheritance, lots of things begin to happen—including a few mysteries that need to be solved. It was a joy to watch mother and daughter interact and get a real sense of their bond. I also loved the romantic sparks between Tara and local garda (police) Declan. He was a gem of a gentleman and fiercely protective and persistent with Tara! And a real asset in retrieving important information the ladies need. There are plenty of lies floating around and they need to uncover the truth concerning Aoife’s father, mother and what become of her sister. There will be some shocking reveals!
There is more than one mystery happening in this story. Beside the mystery of Eithne’s past and those surrounding her, some troubling incidents are happening to Tara, who sent her husband packing when he betrayed her. What she discovers about him will be both disturbing and liberating. She goes through some changes and feels unexpected emotions. Roone Bay and its residents will make a big impact on her heart and even send her life in a different direction. Her mother, too, in facing the past and sifting through the ruins, finds her own freedom after encountering plenty of surprises—and laying ghosts to rest.
This is a heart gripping novel that will shake and rattle you to the core with the horrors of abuse and prejudice that prevailed far too long. But amid the trauma, out of the ashes of grief, love sparks and the novel ends on a very positive and uplifting note. Family secrets, romantic relationships, twin bonds, mystery adventures, second chances, tearful reunions and more are at the centre of this novel. I could not set it down and read it through the night. Definitely recommend. 5 Stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Thanks to Bookouture and Netgalley for the ARC.
